Wed 11 Mar 2009, 11:11 GMT

Coast Guard releases Cosco Busan findings


Investigation report outlines the contributing factors that led to the 2007 bunker spill.



The U.S. Coast Guard has released the marine casualty investigation report for the November 7th 2007 collision involving the 900-foot Cosco Busan vessel and the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge.

The report outlines the contributing factors that led to the accident that resulted in the discharge of more than 53,000 gallons of oil into San Francisco Bay.

The report indicates the main causes of the accident were:

* Navigational error by the pilot of the Cosco Busan, who navigated the vessel at a high, unsafe speed in near-zero visibility, failed to properly monitor the vessel's position and progress, and lost situational awareness;

* Failure of the master of the Cosco Busan to adequately monitor the navigational actions of the pilot and to maintain sufficient situational awareness to question or correct navigational errors made by the pilot;

* Failure of the pilot and master to effectively communicate relevant navigational information with each other during the course of the voyage leading up to the casualty;

* Failure of the pilot and master to conduct a proper pilot-master exchange prior to getting underway;

* Failure of the master to adhere to restricted-visibility procedures in the vessel's safety management system; and

* Failure of the pilot and Cosco Busan's crew to employ proper bridge management team principles.

The US Coast Guard said the purpose of its marine casualty investigation was to "examine the causes of a marine casualty and to make recommendations to help avoid a similar incident."

The marine casualty investigation does not address spill response operations in detail.

The oil spill response was extensively investigated when the Coast Guard chartered a multi-agency Incident Specific Preparedness Review panel.

The panel issued a detailed report of its findings in Jan. 2008 and reported that despite early incorrect spill quantity estimates, spill response personnel acted on a "worst case scenario" basis, resulting in one of the most aggressive and successful responses in recent history, yielding an approximate 40 percent recovery rate of spilled oil.


Alisios vessel. Axpo completes first LNG bunkering in Valencia, with over half bio-LNG  

Ship-to-ship transfer to a container vessel makes Valencia the company's fourth Spanish port for LNG bunkering.

Christening ceremony of Makua vessel. Matson christens Makua, first of three LNG-ready Aloha Class container ships  

Dual-fuel vessel, due for delivery in early 2027, is the first of three ships worth around $1bn.

CMB.Tech logo. CMB.Tech seeks Singapore-based ammonia operations manager for Asia Pacific  

New hire will oversee ammonia chartering and bunkering and liaise with Far East partners.

Lumi Aurora vessel. IINO Lines deploys first Ice Class IB VLGC on long-term charter to Borouge International  

LPG-fuelled Lumi Aurora will carry North American gas to Borouge International's Porvoo plant in Finland.

Abelina Wagenborg vessel launch. Wagenborg launches first EasyMax 2.0 vessel, prepared for methanol, ammonia and LNG  

Abelina Wagenborg, built at Niestern Sander, is the first of a new generation designed for multiple alternative fuels.

NYK and MISC joint venture signing. NYK–MISC joint venture signs charter for 18,700-cbm LNG carrier with Malaysia LNG  

Asia LNG Transport will operate the dual-fuel diesel-electric newbuild, due from Hudong-Zhonghua in 2028, on routes to Japan.

Tsuneishi logo. Study finds methanol dual-fuel retrofit of Kamsarmax bulk carrier would take about 75 days  

Report by Mærsk Mc-Kinney Møller Center, involving Tsuneishi, puts conversion costs at 25–30% of the cost of a conventionally fuelled newbuilding.

LR, Shell and GTT joint development project (JDP) launch. Lloyd's Register, Shell and GTT launch joint project on hybrid-electric 200,000-cbm LNG carrier  

Partners to develop a concept combining hybrid-electric propulsion with GTT NEXT1 cargo containment technology for larger LNG carriers.

ClearMariner homepage. ClearMariner expands maritime sanctions screening with ESG, emissions and API support  

Online service now combines sanctions checks with voyage CO₂, CII, EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime estimates.

Long Jing Xin, Flex Commodities. Flex Commodities adds Long Jing Xin to Singapore marine fuels team  

Company appoints associate for marine fuels as part of plan for regional expansion.