Tue 22 Nov 2011, 14:52 GMT

Boating industry evaluates butanol


Butanol-blended fuels are tested to determine if they could be a better alternative for the boating industry.



The US National Marine Manufacturers Association (NMMA) has released a report, provided by Gevo, Inc., which evaluates the use of isobutanol as a petroleum blendstock for the boating industry.

Over the summer, the NMMA conducted two tests, an emissions test and a product test, to evaluate the effects of butanol-blended fuels in a harsh marine environment. The project aimed to determine if isobutanol could be a better alternative to ethanol blends for the boating industry.

Commenting on the NMMA and American Boat and Yacht Council (ABYC) isobutanol research, NMMA President Thomas Dammrich [pictured] said: "We are pleased with the results of the isobutanol evaluation and look forward to more testing on this, and other, important alternatives to E15. We know E15 causes significant damage to boat engines and therefore rushing it to the market is irresponsible and an unnecessary step, especially in light of the promising test results on isobutanol."

The emissions tests compared a 16.1 percent isobutanol blend to indolene, the standard gasoline used for engine testing. The test used a sampling unit that was developed for a greenhouse gas study carried out by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the NMMA. The evaluation showed that there was a reduction of carbon monoxide from the isobutanol blended fuel, compared to indolene. The results also showed that hydrocarbons and nitrogen oxide emissions were virtually the same between the two fuels.

"It's great to have another third party verify the benefits of isobutanol," said Chris Ryan, president and COO of Gevo. "The product attributes of isobutanol, made in retrofitted ethanol plants, can solve the problems associated with current generation biofuels. Isobutanol is compatible with all gasoline engines and infrastructure like pipelines and fuel pumps. These benefits make it a very promising biofuel additive that can help the nation achieve greater energy independence and align the interests of farmers, ethanol plant owners, refiners, engine manufacturers and consumers."

The emissions tests were not the only positive results seen. When comparing isobutanol to ethanol for use in boating, several of isobutanol's key benefits emerged. Isobutanol can be blended into gasoline at higher percentages than ethanol, and unlike ethanol-blended gasoline, isobutanol blends do not cause phase separation when water enters a boat's fuel system. This is said to be a critical distinction between ethanol and isobutanol blends.

A PowerPoint presentation containing the evaluation's findings can be found by visiting the following address:

http://www.nmma.org/assets/cabinets/Cabinet432/Summer%20Butanol%20Evaluation%20Presentation.pdf

Image: Thomas Dammrich, President of the National Marine Manufacturers Association (NMMA)


Athens cityscape. Angelicoussis Group seeks senior marine fuels desk lead in Athens  

Greek shipping group advertises senior bunker procurement role requiring 15 years' experience.

BP logo. BP seeks marine commercial manager in London to support global marine fuels business  

Role at BP Marine falls under BP's GDIST unit — part of its Trading & Shipping (T&S) division.

Hiroyuki Takumi and Wolfgang Dunger. Mitsui E&S completes factory acceptance test of Japan’s first WinGD methanol dual-fuel engine  

Engine set to be installed on the first of four vessels being built for a domestic shipowner.

mtu Series 2000 generator set. Rolls-Royce Power Systems to showcase variable-speed gensets and SCR systems at SMM 2026  

New mtu Series 2000 units claim up to 15% fuel and CO₂ savings over constant-speed alternatives.

CMA CGM Roi Arthur naming ceremony. CMA CGM names 15,000-teu methanol-powered vessel Roi Arthur  

Newbuild joins the French carrier's REX2 service connecting East Asia with the Red Sea.

Quadrise and Licella logo. Quadrise and Licella update joint development agreement to advance HTL-derived marine biofuels  

Amended deal sets a clearer testing roadmap for bio-oil-based emulsion fuels for shipping.

Clean Star vessel. Atlas Maritime takes delivery of dual-fuel LNG PCTC, secures $80,000/day charter  

The 7,000 RT car carrier has been placed on a two-year time charter at a rate Atlas calls record-breaking.

Kota Eagle ship-to-ship (STS) bunkering operation. PIL’s Kota Eagle helps Shanghai pass 2 million cbm LNG bunkering mark  

Milestone said to have been reached when boxship received 4,549 cbm of LNG from SIPG Energy’s LNG bunkering vessel.

Keel-laying ceremony for B100-compatible vessel. Pinnacle Marine lays keel for fourth B100-compatible harbour craft in Singapore newbuild programme  

Singapore operator expands its B100-compatible fleet amid strong chartering demand.

E-fuels volumes per country. Europe risks falling behind China in race to produce e-fuels for shipping  

Europe has 69 e-fuel projects but only six are operational, while China is scaling rapidly.