Wed 10 Apr 2013, 12:24 GMT

Castrol challenges SDA methodology


Lube firm expresses concerns over the rigour of some scavenge drain oil analysis techniques used to verify lubricant performance.



Concerns over corrosive wear risk in cross-head engines have led Castrol Marine to question the rigour of some widely used scavenge drain oil analysis (SDA) techniques.

Factors influencing scavenge drain oil characteristics include fuel sulphur level, cylinder oil BN level, system oil contamination and operating profile. Accuracy is critical in SDA interpretation, not least because it supports feed-rate assumptions that are critical to cylinder oil performance, Castrol says.

"It is not possible to analyse results accurately without comprehensive knowledge of the fuel oil, the new and used system oil, feed rates and operational data collected from the engine at the time of sampling," commented Paul Harrold, Castrol Marine Technology Manager. "Our view is that there are potential shortcomings in ship-based magnetic analyser type SDA approaches because they cannot identify corrosive wear."

Cylinder wear could be assumed to be under control due to a low response on ferro-magnetic analysers where, in fact, corrosion is taking place, Harrold said. "This demands attention as evidence grows supporting our position that corrosive wear risk is going unacknowledged when cylinder oils of insufficient BN are used in slow steaming."

MAN Diesel revised guidance to customers on mid-range BN cylinder oils at the end of 2012, recommending cylinder lube oil with 70BN or higher to customers for its newest Series 9 engines when running on higher sulphur fuel (above 1.5%- 2%). The firm says it “cannot recommend” cylinder oils "with a BN level between 50 and 60" for its latest engines.

Suppliers promoting mid-range BNs for slow steaming have argued that Series 9 engines represent only a small part of the current fleet. However, Castrol notes that mid-range cylinder oils were initially claimed as a complete solution for all conditions.

"We make no apology for renewing counselling caution on SDA methodology as the full consequences of lubricant selection when slow steaming continue to emerge,” said Mr Harrold. “Onboard SDA does not cover the full picture on cylinder oil feed rate optimisation. Normal corrosive wear patterns generate iron compounds which are predominantly non-magnetic and are thus not detected by onboard analysers."


Molslinjen vessel render. AYK Energy secures battery contract for Molslinjen's electric fast ferries  

Battery maker to supply 165MWh for three electric catamarans after cutting system weight by nearly half.

Giosue Vezzuto, RINA. Giosuè Vezzuto named CEO of RINA Services, taking charge of marine and certification arm  

Naval engineer with nearly three decades at RINA succeeds Paolo Moretti to lead the group's marine and certification division.

Acta Aquarius vessel. Acta Marine completes four-vessel newbuild programme with delivery of methanol dual-fuel Acta Aquarius  

Dutch offshore support vessel operator takes delivery of its fourth Tersan-built CSOV, featuring dual-fuel methanol propulsion.

Wind-assisted vessel illustration. Lloyd's Register backs GCMD methodology for verifying wind propulsion fuel savings  

Independent review aims to boost confidence in wind-assisted propulsion performance and unlock sustainable finance for energy-efficiency retrofits.

CM Wuhan vessel. China Merchants delivers first methanol dual-fuel ro-ro vessel classed solely by CCS  

The 7,800-CEU CM Wuhan is the first methanol dual-fuel ro-ro vessel classed solely by China Classification Society.

Andre M ammonia-fuelled gas carrier. China delivers first domestically built ammonia-fuelled gas carrier  

CCS-classed vessel becomes the world's second ammonia-fuelled gas carrier, testing rules for the IMO's zero-carbon shipping transition.

Nordion Energi liquefied biogas (LBG) facility render. Storage tank installed as Gothenburg's LBG bunkering plant advances towards 2027 completion  

Nordion Energi's liquefied biogas facility at the Port of Gothenburg takes a step forward with tank installation.

Maran Myron vessel. Maran Tankers takes delivery of dual-fuel Suezmax Maran Myron  

Vessel is sixth dual-fuel tanker in eight-vessel series built by New Times Shipbuilding.

Lake Victoria truck-to-ship (TTS) bunkering operation. EPS completes first truck-to-ship LNG bunkering operation in Davisville  

Fuel delivered to the pure car and truck carrier Lake Victoria whilst at berth.

Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore logo. MPA opens applications for LNG floating storage unit licences  

Singapore invites applications for up to two LNG floating storage unit licences to bolster bunkering supply resilience.