Tue 9 Sep 2008, 08:03 GMT

Study: Cleaner fuels have zero GHG impact


Researchers claim use of cleaner fuels has a net zero impact on greenhouse gas emissions.



A new study carried out in the United States claims to demonstrate that the production and distribution of "cleaner" marine fuels creates a net zero impact on greenhouse gas emissions.

James Winebrake, Professor and Chair of the Department of Science, Technology and Society/Public Policy at Rochester Institute of Technology, and James Corbett, associate professor in the College of Marine and Earth Studies at the University of Delaware examined "Emission Tradeoffs among Alternative Marine Fuels: Total Fuel Cycle Analysis of Residual Oil, Marine Gas Oil, and Marine Diesel Oil," in a recent issue of Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association.

According to Winebrake and Corbett, reducing fuel sulphur content is an essential component of any strategy aimed at reducing sulphur oxide emissions from marine vessels - especially since global concerns have caused policy makers to accelerate the introduction of emission control technologies and cleaner fuels into the international marine sector. These tactics aim to improve air quality and human health and mitigate climate change.

"Cleaner fuels are expected to reduce sulfur and particulate emissions, however, greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions may increase because of the additional refining energy required to produce these fuels - residual oil, marine gas oil and marine diesel oil," Winebrake explained. "Our study provides a total fuel cycle emissions analysis to help quantify these emissions tradeoffs."

In the study, the two professors applied a jointly developed model called the Total Energy and Emissions Analysis for Marine Systems (TEAMS) model, which was developed to explore what are called "upstream" emissions associated with fuel production and distribution. Using the model, the authors reportedly demonstrated that although cleaner fuels increase GHG emissions during their production, they reduce GHG emissions during vessel operation, creating almost a net zero GHG impact.

The result was counter to claims which suggested that the use of cleaner fuels in the marine sector would exacerbate GHG problems.

"Given that the GHG impacts associated with cleaner fuels are almost nil, and given the tremendous advantages of these fuels with respect to other pollutants, policies that encourage cleaner fuels seem warranted," said Winebrake, who also published a paper last year with Corbett reportedly demonstrating significant premature human mortality across the globe due to emissions from ships.

"The global shipping sector is one of the last unregulated emissions sources, and our study will provide useful information to the ongoing international debate surrounding cleaner marine fuels," said Winebrake.


Maritime Technologies Forum (MTF) logo. MTF issues safety management guidelines for methanol-fuelled ships  

New MTF report offers recommendations for developing and strengthening safety management systems for methanol as a fuel.

Kapitan Dranitsyn icebreaker. European shipowners call for permanent EU ETS derogations for islands, outermost regions and ice-classed vessels  

ECSA urges the European Commission to extend maritime ETS exemptions beyond 2030 ahead of directive revision.

Global Maritime Forum logo. Compliance pooling could help unlock investment in zero-emission marine fuels, says Getting to Zero Coalition  

A new insight brief argues pooling models must evolve to support long-term e-fuels offtake.

Levante LNG and Legend of the Seas STS bunkering operation. Peninsula performs maiden bio-LNG delivery in Cádiz  

Bunker firm has now supplied all three of Royal Caribbean Group’s Icon-class vessels with bio-LNG.

Shawn Ho, Oilmar. Oilmar appoints Shawn Ho as senior manager for business development and bunker trading in Singapore  

Marine fuel seller hires experienced industry professional to bolster its Singapore operations.

Island Horizon vessel. Island Oil expands fleet with acquisition of two tankers for Mediterranean operations  

Island Polaris and Island Horizon join bunker firm's fleet of vessels.

Meera naming ceremony. Naming ceremony held for LPG dual-fuel ammonia carrier  

VLAC Meera named during event held in China on 10 July.

IMO Council 137th session IMO adopts Singapore-led resolution on protection of shipping lanes  

Thirty co-sponsors back a resolution reaffirming navigational rights under international law.

TT-Line Green Ship 2.0 illustration. TT-Line orders second LNG-hybrid battery ferry for Baltic Sea operations  

German ferry operator doubles down on LNG-hybrid technology with a second next-generation newbuild.

CMA CGM Notre Dame and Gas Agility ship-to-ship (STS) bunkering operation. CMA CGM Notre Dame receives first European bio-LNG bunkering during Rotterdam maiden call  

LNG-powered container ship takes on bio-LNG derived from agricultural waste.