This is a legacy page. Please click here to view the latest version.
Thu 14 Jun 2018, 07:42 GMT

Increased supply chain transparency will solve contamination issues: Tolson


Calls for improved understanding of the provenance of products within the bunker supply chain.


Adrian Tolson, Senior Partner at 20|20 Marine Energy.
Image credit: 20|20 Marine Energy
Maritime consultancy 20|20 Marine Energy says the shipping industry and bunkering sector face significant challenges in relation to contamination post 2020 if there is not a better understanding of the provenance of products within the marine fuel supply chain, clarity on the quality and formulation of what is being purchased, and a fundamental commitment to not continually repeat the same mistakes of the past.

The comments follow recent reports regarding fuel contamination issues on over 30 vessels in the Houston area.

20|20 Marine Energy notes that it is also aware of rumours between February and April 2018 regarding a significant outbreak of fuel quality issues in the US Gulf Coast, with estimations of as many as 100 vessels seeking claims due to fuel quality, which are understood to have caused a number of technical problems, including - in some cases - a complete loss of engine power, and which are said to extend to the Panama Canal.

"The Gulf Coast last saw a series of contamination claims in 2013. However, in 2007 a myriad of claims with supply origins in the Gulf Coast tore their way through the entire global bunkering industry, impacting almost every major supply port," said Adrian Tolson, Senior Partner, 20|20 Marine Energy.

"These problems continue to happen again, and again, the same mistakes continue to be made and it looks like the industry is operating in a state of blissful amnesia. It needs to change."

"Firstly, the industry needs to see more transparency and clarity around products. We believe that now is the time for blenders and suppliers to fully warrant the quality of their fuel, even if it is sold within the Platts window. Secondly, suppliers should no longer be able to hide behind the fact that products just 'meet ISO specifications', when in reality they are not fit for purpose, and contravene Clause 5 of ISO 8217. And finally, there needs to be a universal increase in knowledge of the fuel supply chain by all parties involved, so that history stops repeating itself, and to ensure that positive change can occur. This is particularly important in a post 2020 world, where there is already concern about the quality of blended products that will flood the market to meet the 0.5% Sulphur limit."

20|20 Marine Energy also believes that there is a correlation between an increase in contamination issues and rising crude and fuel prices, where prices increase to a point where producers can get a better return from the bunker supply chain, rather than selling into normal outlets.

Tolson continued: "2007 and 2013 were eras of peak bunker prices, so it is no surprise that we are now dealing with this problem with fuel oil now rising to $400 per ton, and crude at over $70 per barrel. The general consensus is that crude will continue to rise post 2020, and suppliers need to get their houses in order. They can no longer use the excuse that margins are under pressure, and that they are being forced to use the cheapest components. In fact, the clever ones will use this situation as an opportunity to build and market their brands around transparency and professionalism, instigating processes, such as warranties that ensures the viability and provenance of their products. Not all will be able to achieve this, and if this means the industry loses a few participants as collateral damage, then so be it. Bunkering will be better for it."


Caspar Gooren, Titan. Titan Clean Fuels signs e-methane supply deal with TURN2X for 2028 delivery  

Bunker supplier to receive e-methane from Spanish production plant for distribution across European ports.

Hydrogen-fuelled engine 6UEC35LSGH. Japan consortium achieves hydrogen co-firing in main engine for large commercial vessel  

Engine reaches over 95% hydrogen co-firing ratio, with installation planned for 2027.

BTB bunker truck. Belgian Trading & Bunkering expands DMA 0.89 truck deliveries in ARA region  

BTB extends marine fuel offerings with truck-based deliveries to meet maritime market demand.

Fuel pathway roundtable meeting participants. ABS convenes roundtable on offshore power barge for Great Lakes emissions reduction  

Meeting brought together ports, academia and industry to advance shore power solution under EPA programme.

Lego Ane Maersk video screenshot. Maersk marks 50-year Lego partnership with dual-fuel vessel model  

Shipping company displays an exhibition of Lego sets spanning five decades at Copenhagen headquarters.

Guo Yun Hai vessel. Cosco Shipping takes delivery of 80,000-dwt methanol-ready grain carrier  

Guo Yun Hai features box-shaped cargo hold and methanol-ready design with energy-saving devices.

CMA CGM Innovation ship-to-ship transfer. Algeciras reports record LNG bunkering volumes, claims European top-three position  

Spanish port says it supplied 333,833 cbm of LNG across 78 ship-to-ship operations in 2025.

Additional costs chart. T&E: Iran conflict costing shipping industry €340m a day in fuel costs  

Transport & Environment analysis shows marine fuel price surge has cost the industry €4.6bn since conflict began.

CF 3850 vessel render. Damen delivers second hybrid-ready combi freighter to German shipowner  

The vessel features biofuel capability and will be retrofitted with wind-assist technology with government funding.

Engine retrofit report 2026 graphic. Retrofit capability expands as regulatory uncertainty slows alternative-fuel conversions  

Lloyd’s Register warns delayed conversions could compress demand into a narrower, costlier timeframe as the fleet ages.


↑  Back to Top