This is a legacy page. Please click here to view the latest version.
Wed 2 May 2018, 12:48 GMT

World Fuel Services in legal battle over alleged non-payment of bunker fuel


Case revolves around fuel delivery to the bulk carrier M/V Triton last year.


Image credit: Pixabay
World Fuel Services (Singapore) Pte Ltd (WFS) has filed a lawsuit in Oregon, US, against the bulk carrier M/V Triton for the alleged non-payment of bunker fuel.

According to court documents seen by Bunker Index, the plaintiff is demanding $279,679.12 as of April 18, which is the total outstanding balance for the fuel, including interest and administrative fees, with interest continuing to accrue at the rate of 2 percent per month until the amount owing is paid in full.

WFS claims that, on or around March 15, 2017, it entered into a contract with the charterer of the Triton - Swiss firm Windrose SPS Shipping and Trading SA - to supply the vessel with marine fuel oil (MFO) at an agreed price of $290 per tonne at the port of Singapore.

WFS says it then subcontracted the supply to Universal Energy Pte. Ltd., which subsequently delivered 746.063 tonnes to the ship on March 20, 2017, and was later paid in full by WFS for the operation.

Charterer Windrose was later sent an invoice on March 27, 2017, for $216,358.27, with the amount to be paid within 30 days of the date of delivery, by April 19, 2017.

Approximately three weeks ago, on or around April 11, 2018, WFS says it sent notice of the outstanding balance due to three parties: Husky Trading, understood to be the registered owner; Diana Shipping Incorporated, said to be the beneficial owner of the ship; and Diana Shipping Services S.A., the commercial operator of the vessel.

In WFS's legal complaint, it demands full payment of the aforementioned US$279,679.12, plus accrued interest and additional fees.

Furthermore, the fuel seller requests that a warrant of arrest be issued against the ship, which was due to arrive at the port of Kalama, Washington, on or around April 18, 2018.

The warrant of arrest was subsequently granted by the court on April 19, 2018 - a year to the day since the invoice was allegedly due to be paid.

Universal Energy

At the time of the Triton bunker delivery, in March 2017, Universal Energy was ranked as the third biggest supplier in Singapore by the Martime and Port Authority of Singapore (MPA). However, as previously reported, just over five months later, the company's bunker supplier licence and bunker craft operator licence were not renewed, and this meant that the company was no longer allowed to operate as a bunker supplier and bunker craft operator in Singapore.

Explaining the reason at the time, the MPA said that Universal Energy had accumulated demerit points for the delivery of "severely aerated" fuel, as well as stoppages during bunkering operations.

No evidence has been presented in WFS's case so far to suggest that there were any fuel quality - or other - issues related to Universal Energy's bunker delivery to the Triton, performed by the MT UE Saphire.

In the original bunker delivery note (BDN), seen by Bunker Index, the customer feedback rating was the highest - '5; Very Satisfied' out of a possible 5 - and no Notice of Protest was issued.

Following its licence ban last year, Universal Energy went into liquidation, facing millions in claims from other companies for unpaid fuel bills.


Sing Fuels logo. Sing Fuels seeks Asia-based supply trader to bolster bunker procurement team  

Singapore bunkering firm is recruiting a supply trader to manage marine fuel purchasing across Asia.

MOL joint naming ceremony. MOL names world's first ammonia-fuelled Capesize bulk carriers  

Naming of Ruri Mirai, Ruri Sekai and Ruri Hikari signals ammonia's arrival as a marine fuel for large bulk carriers.

Washington State Hybrid-Electric 160-Auto Ferry vessel render. ABB wins Washington State Ferries' third hybrid-electric vessel order  

ABB extends its role in the US ferry operator's electrification programme, which targets emission-free operations by 2050.

Aurora Borealis vessel. Kawasaki Heavy Industries delivers LPG-fuelled carrier Aurora Borealis  

Ship could also be modified in future to allow for ammonia-fuelled operation.

Rendering of Estonia's first shore-charged electric ferry. Estonian State Fleet's shore-charged electric ferry completes model testing in Germany  

Hull and propulsion tests show the vessel's energy consumption remains within contracted limits with room to spare.

Kypros Island vessel. Tsuneishi delivers first methanol dual-fuel Kamsarmax bulk carrier from Chinese yard  

Shipbuilder claims progress towards establishing a mass-production system for vessels designed to reduce environmental impact.

ZIM LNG container vessel. Los Angeles and Long Beach identify LNG and methanol as key near-term marine fuels  

Joint feasibility study maps out demand projections and infrastructure needs to support cleaner shipping fuels at San Pedro Bay

Alexander Treff, Christiania Energy, Christiania Energy welcomes student assistant to Copenhagen office  

Alexander Treff joins marine fuels firm while studying international business at Copenhagen Business School.

Carlotta Cosulich vessel. Cosulich Marine Energy takes delivery of third methanol-ready bunker tanker  

Carlotta Cosulich joins the group’s fleet, bringing its four-vessel bunkering programme closer to completion.

Rendering of a Wallenius Wilhelmsen vessel Wallenius Wilhelmsen orders four dual-fuel PCTCs, extends fleet renewal programme  

Shipping firm signs for LNG-fuelled car carriers with options for eight more, with deliveries from 2030.


↑  Back to Top