This is a legacy page. Please click here to view the latest version.
Fri 4 Nov 2016, 09:45 GMT

LNG marine fuel could be worse for environment than HFO, says former IBIA CEO


Ian Adams: 'The LNG myth has progressed unchecked'.



Liquefied natural gas (LNG) is not a panacea to reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and its increasing use as a marine fuel could be worse for the environment than burning heavy fuel oil, according to Ian Adams, the former CEO of the International Bunker Industry Association (IBIA).

With reports claiming that the use of LNG as a marine fuel can reduce the industry's CO2 emissions by 75 percent, Adams, who is often called upon as an expert witness in bunker dispute cases, said: "Whilst it is well documented that LNG is an excellent solution for reducing SOx and NOx emissions, I am dismayed to see it being promoted as a solution for reducing GHGs."

Referring to a Reuters interview with Bernhard Schulte Group's corporate director of energy projects, Angus Campbell, Adams remarked: "It is a complete falsehood to suggest, as Reuters has, that 'global efforts to cut carbon dioxide emissions will be key for the adoption of liquefied natural gas (LNG) as a marine fuel'."

Adams, a fellow of the Institute of Marine Engineering, Science & Technology who now heads the Association of Bulk Terminal Operators, said: "The energy content of LNG is slightly more than half that of fuel oil, so to extract the same energy output when consuming LNG rather than fuel oil it is necessary to consume almost twice the volume of LNG. Whilst the chemical makeup of LNG will admittedly result in a slightly lower CO2 emission, it is certainly not a large magnitude; but there is another important consideration: LNG is principally methane. With methane recognised as a GHG and widely considered to be twenty-five times more harmful than CO2, it would only require a 4 percent slip through the supply chain to equal the CO2 emissions from the industry's current consumption of heavy fuel oil.

"If we, rather generously, accept that burning LNG will reduce CO2 emissions by 20 percent over the current level, it would require less than 1 percent slip for there to be no gain from a GHG perspective. Taken over the entire supply chain, 1 percent is not an unrealistic slip. Unfortunately, the LNG myth has progressed unchecked with very few challenging those lobbying for a wider take up of LNG."

Adams' comments follow the recent decision by the International Maritime Organisation (IMO) to implement a global 0.5% cap on the sulphur content of marine fuel in January 2020, and to adopt mandatory requirements for ships of 5,000 gross tonnage (gt) and above to collect consumption data for each type of fuel oil they use in order to provide information for future decisions on additional measures to reduce shipping's greenhouse gas emissions.


Molslinjen vessel render. AYK Energy secures battery contract for Molslinjen's electric fast ferries  

Battery maker to supply 165MWh for three electric catamarans after cutting system weight by nearly half.

Giosue Vezzuto, RINA. Giosuè Vezzuto named CEO of RINA Services, taking charge of marine and certification arm  

Naval engineer with nearly three decades at RINA succeeds Paolo Moretti to lead the group's marine and certification division.

Acta Aquarius vessel. Acta Marine completes four-vessel newbuild programme with delivery of methanol dual-fuel Acta Aquarius  

Dutch offshore support vessel operator takes delivery of its fourth Tersan-built CSOV, featuring dual-fuel methanol propulsion.

Wind-assisted vessel illustration. Lloyd's Register backs GCMD methodology for verifying wind propulsion fuel savings  

Independent review aims to boost confidence in wind-assisted propulsion performance and unlock sustainable finance for energy-efficiency retrofits.

CM Wuhan vessel. China Merchants delivers first methanol dual-fuel ro-ro vessel classed solely by CCS  

The 7,800-CEU CM Wuhan is the first methanol dual-fuel ro-ro vessel classed solely by China Classification Society.

Andre M ammonia-fuelled gas carrier. China delivers first domestically built ammonia-fuelled gas carrier  

CCS-classed vessel becomes the world's second ammonia-fuelled gas carrier, testing rules for the IMO's zero-carbon shipping transition.

Nordion Energi liquefied biogas (LBG) facility render. Storage tank installed as Gothenburg's LBG bunkering plant advances towards 2027 completion  

Nordion Energi's liquefied biogas facility at the Port of Gothenburg takes a step forward with tank installation.

Maran Myron vessel. Maran Tankers takes delivery of dual-fuel Suezmax Maran Myron  

Vessel is sixth dual-fuel tanker in eight-vessel series built by New Times Shipbuilding.

Lake Victoria truck-to-ship (TTS) bunkering operation. EPS completes first truck-to-ship LNG bunkering operation in Davisville  

Fuel delivered to the pure car and truck carrier Lake Victoria whilst at berth.

Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore logo. MPA opens applications for LNG floating storage unit licences  

Singapore invites applications for up to two LNG floating storage unit licences to bolster bunkering supply resilience.


↑  Back to Top